How to Fix a Broken Shower Handle? (Find Out!)

A broken shower handle can happen to anyone at any time. And unfortunately, there’s no sign to guess the event. Unless it’s one wobbly, almost given up, and poorly maintained old shower handle we are talking about. Then, it’s sort of predictable!

No matter which one is the case with you, learning how to fix a broken shower handle will help.

To fix a broken shower handle, you can try a temporary fix or go for a longer-term solution. Using supplies like plumbing tape and epoxy can work as an instant way out. But most of the time, that won’t be enough. You’ll need to replace the shower handle, which is a more permanent fix.

Today in this guide, I will suggest some advice to deal with a broken shower handle situation in a better way. Hopefully, It Will Help!

Short-Term and Long-Term Solutions to Fix a Broken Shower Handle

Before trying any long-term fix, you may need to sort the situation out temporarily. So I will share both routes. But first, there’s something else to take care of. Now that the shower handle is broken, exactly how to turn off the water as it could be running?

You can either:

Now that the water is not running anymore, you can move ahead and wonder exactlywhy did my shower handle stop working?

Your shower handle will stop working if there’s wear and tear on the cartridge or stem. Most of the time, it happens from a broken shower handle stem. However, a broken shower handle cartridge can also be responsible.

With a broken shower handle, it’s initially the components that are damaged. However, it is also possible that the shower handle was wrecked out of nowhere. It may seem weird at first, as with normal usage breaking a fixture is quite not likely.

The Shower Handle May Suddenly Break If:

Short-Term Solutions to Fix a Broken Shower Handle

So as a temporary fix, what to do when your shower handle is broken?Before you can arrange for a more permanent solution.

When your shower handle is broken, you can temporarily fix it by sealing the cracks using plumbers’ tape or epoxy sealant. Replacing the handle stem may also be needed if the valve is damaged. And in that case, both of these temporary fixes won’t work.

As you are figuring out how to fix the shower knob that fell off, consider the extent of the breakage. Depending on that, you can make a choice whether to use epoxy sealant or a plumber’s tape.

This Is How It Goes:

None of these would work if the broken handle had a damaged valve. You may require changing the stem valve in that case.

This requires removing the handle and trimming the plate to access the broken valve stem. You need to pull out the damaged valve stem but that can be difficult sometimes due to corrosion.

A rust remover spray can loosen things up for easy removal. If you need to get one, then instead of the regular variants, go for Goof Off Rust Remover as it is targeted for bathroom fixtures. That way, you can use it later again.

After this, you need to install the new replacement valve stem. Finish things off by reinstalling the trim plate with fresh caulk around it and screwing back the shower handle in place.

You May Need Replacement to Fix a Broken Shower Handle – The Long Term Fix!

Do shower handles wear outwith regular usage? Of course, they do!

Shower handles will wear out just like any other plumbing fixture. And this happens based on how frequently the shower is used and how much maintenance/repairs the shower unit gets.

Also, this has to do a lot with understanding exactly how long a shower handle lasts. You see, if it’s high time for the old shower handle to retire, then considering the replacement might just be the case anyway.

Usually, a shower handle should last you well for at least four to five years. This can, of course be more or less depending on how well-maintained you keep the entire space. Also, you must consider how many times the shower handle components were repaired/changed.

Replacing a shower (broken or damaged) will be the best long-term fix. It is simply the most stress-free solution for those who don’t want to invest their time wondering and preaching about it.

Now can you replace just the shower handle, or does it require changing more than that?

Yes, you can replace just the shower handle if none of the other parts is malfunctioning. However, sometimes it may require replacing the valves if there are signs of damage.

Shower Handle Compatibility

One more question on the broken shower knob that I want to include is about its compatibility.

Can I replace the shower handle with any brand? If that’s what you are wondering, then stop right there.

You may want to replace the shower handle with any brand; however the valve is not interchangeable. And that is why you should stick with the same manufacturer when buying a replacement shower handle. Also, the handle style must be compatible.

And usually, the best way to ensure a similar handle style is to find one within the same brand. You can bring the old handle with its screw to a local plumbing hardware store.

It will be easy for you to find the same size/brand handle this way. Don’t forget to match the material of the knob with your existing bathroom fixtures too.

How to Replace a Shower Handle

I am going to give you a simple breakdown of the general replacement process. Keep in mind, depending on the handle style, brand, additional elements, and other factors some extra steps might be required.

If you are trying to replace a 3-handle shower faucet that won’t turn off, it might require further steps. Similarly, replacing a two-handle shower valve with the handle assembly can be different.

To be sure of it, don’t forget to check the manual.

1. Disconnect Water Supply

Turn off the water supply by shutting the valve or the main water supply of your home. Release all the water from the shower as well.

2. Remove the Cover Plate and Handle Screw

Use a utility knife or a flathead screwdriver to gently push underneath the decorative trimming/cover plate on the knob and try to lift it. This will help to pry off the cover plate. You can use a handle puller if the cover plate is stuck.

A center screw shall be holding the knob, you need to unscrew it using a Phillips screwdriver. Be ready to catch the screw, as it will fall out suddenly. Having a cloth over the shower drain will help catch this small screw easily.

3. Remove the Handle

Now start twisting the handle in a counterclockwise direction to detach it from the valve. If it feels stuck then you can tap on it with a hammer (light strokes) and break the buildup causing the issue.

4. Placing the New Handle

Depending on whether you are installing double handles or single handles, the instruction can be slightly varying here.

For a Single Handle:

For Double Handles:

5. Reinstall/Replace Cover Plate

Finally, the replacement is complete, and you can reinstall the cover plate back in its place. If the plate seems old and worn out, consider replacing it as well. Make sure the cover sits flat and flush with the handle.

Wrapping Up

You now know how to fix a broken shower handle. I hope there will be no problem with handling the situation from this point.

However, if you do face confusion, don’t hesitate to contact a professional for help. These fixtures can feel complicated to handle sometimes. Especially if you have less experience dealing with similar problems.

I will see you again in my next guide, bye!